top of page

Can you sustain a win-win mindset in a zero-sum game?

From my experience, navigating the choppy waters of negotiation, especially in scenarios where the pie seems too small to share, requires not just skill but a deep understanding of human nature and fairness. Let me share some insights and practical examples that highlights the power of a win-win mindset, even when the odds suggest a zero-sum game.

Fair Process: I once led a negotiation where all parties were aiming for the last portion of a pie. Rather than engaging in a contentious struggle, we prioritised fair discussion to ensure mutual needs were understood. This emphasis on fairness was paramount, especially during a contract renewal amid a budget freeze. Rather than imposing cost cuts at the supplier's expense, we collaborated to reduce expenses without sacrificing quality. By upholding transparency and adhering to shared criteria, both parties found the outcome fair and equitable, even within the constraints of limited resources.

Understanding and Respect: There was a time when a critical negotiation seemed doomed from the start. The other party and we were miles apart in our expectations. Instead of digging in, we each took a step back to truly listen and understand the constraints and pressures the other was under. This empathy didn't change the size of the pie but changed how we felt about the division. We respected each other's bottom lines and found a middle ground that, while not perfect, felt fair to both. It was like two climbers tethered together, knowing that the success of one depended on the safety of the other.

Creative Solutions: Consider the classic dilemma of two departments fighting over a limited budget. Instead of a winner-takes-all outcome, we looked beyond the immediate battle to find creative solutions. We jointly proposed a shared project that would benefit both departments and, in turn, received a budget increase from the Executive Board, impressed by our collaborative spirit.

Future Opportunities: In one memorable negotiation, the immediate pie was fixed, and competition was fierce. However, by focusing not just on the present but on the potential for future collaborations, we were able to frame the negotiation as a stepping stone to a larger, more beneficial relationship. We agreed to terms that were perhaps not ideal for either party in the moment but opened the door to a multi-year partnership that would bring much greater gains to both sides.

Through these experiences, I've learnt that negotiation is less about the immediate spoils and more about the journey, the relationships, and the bridges you build along the way. Even when the pie seems too small, a win-win mindset can create outcomes where everyone feels like they've gained, not necessarily in terms of material benefits only but in respect, understanding, and future possibilities.


bottom of page